Tuesday, November 25, 2008

A New Project for SETI

The Cepheid Galactic Internet

J.G. Learned, R.P. Kudritzki, S. Pakvasa, and A. Zee

arXiv:0809.0339v2

URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0339

This paper puts forward an interesting proposition for intergalactic communication: frequency modulation of cepheid variable stars.

Cepheids are 1,000 to 10,000 times brighter than our sun and have regular, detectable variations in brightness with a period of 1-50 days. The frequency and luminosity are strongly correlated, so one can measure the period of the stars, deduce the luminosity, compare with the observed brightness, and determine how far away the star is. Parallax is used to calibrate the distance scale on nearby cepheids.

The authors of this paper propose that an advanced race might intentionally modify the period of these stars to send information throughout the galaxy: FM at very low frequencies!

The mechanism by which the brightness varies is similar to the charging and discharging of a capacitor. According to the authors, as the star consumes hydrogen through nuclear fusion, ionized helium builds up on the surface of the star. This decreases the luminosity and increases the temperature of the star. This is followed by "violent expansion and deionization," after which the cycle repeats.

It is interesting that an avalanche process like this leads to a regular cycle of variations in the brightness. The same thing happens in circuits with a capacitor (if I remember my physics lab correctly). A build up of charge is followed by dielectric breakdown (a spark) after which the process repeats. The spark frequency is constant. What makes these systems different from, say, a pile of sand? The avalanches in a sand pile have a power law distribution in both size and frequency. What makes the two systems so different? I assume the circuit and the cepheid have nice, normal, linear equations of motion while the sand pile is governed by nonlinear equations. But what parameter differentiates the two? Is there some control parameter in the circuit that would lead to a crossover between periodic sparks and a frequency distribution more like the avalanches in the sand pile?

I digress. The reason I described the process that gives rise to the periodic variations in a cepheid is that the authors claim it can be influenced by external agents. They suggest that the deionization could be triggered early with a sufficient burst of power. The variation in the period could be used to transmit messages. To make the star fire early, the authors suggest that a neutrino beam focused on the star's core might do the trick.

The authors suggest the neutrino beam could be generated by a large space station orbiting the star running on solar power. We've got a long way to go from our handheld calculators to star-altering neutrino beams! For a society that could build such a device, it would seem a simple matter to build the beacon and leave it in place.

So are aliens broadcasting over the cepheid Internet? The authors say it wouldn't be too hard to find out. Normally astronomers measure the average period of these variable stars. Averaging the data would, of course, wash out any signal. Rather than determining the average, one would simply have to bin the data and look for a splitting of the signal around the fundamental frequency.

The authors don't mention it, but one might also perform an entropy analysis of the time series data. A periodic source would have zero entropy, while a modulated source would appear more ergodic. This would be a secondary analysis. If a splitting of the fundamental peak in the frequency spectrum were observed, one would then analyze the time series data to see if the splitting is also periodic, or if it has more structure to it.

Calling this system a galactic Internet is a bit misleading. It's more like the galactic telegraph. An early flash corresponds to a 1, an on-time flash corresponds to 0. Only one bit can be sent per period, so the maximum transmission rate is on the order of 1 bit per month. It would take forever to download a page from Encyclopedia Galactica!

I wonder what types of message would be transmitted. There seem to be two schools of thought about aliens: the Star Trek school, and the Hitchhiker school. The former envision alien civilizations as refined, peaceful, rational, and technologically advanced. The latter imagine alien civilizations to be more like our own society, with profit-driven pleasure-seekers, petty bickering, advertising, and bureaucracy. Each would certainly use the galactic beacon to transmit different kinds of messages.

The Star Trek variety of civilization might use the beacon as a lighthouse, a simple welcome message for young civilizations pointing them to a source of information with more bandwidth, or a galactic emergency broadcast system. If the cepheids were run by Hitchhikers, we might instead find messages like "Tresspassers will be shot on sight" or "Eat at Joe's." Imagine, after years of trying to crack the code, we discovered the message to be

"At the next pulse, the current time will be ..."

Monday, November 24, 2008

Hidden Interactions?

Hidden One-Electron Interactions in Carbon Nanotubes Revealed in Graphene Nanostrips

C.T. White, J. Li, D. Gunlycke, and J.W. Mintmire

Nanoletters 7, 825--830 (2007)

URL: http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/nl0627745


The authors explore the band gap of graphene nanoribbons. I was disappointed to discover that the "hidden interactions‚" they refer to are second and third nearest neighbor couplings that must be added to the tight binding model to reproduce the results of a density functional calculation. They predict that all armchair edge nanoribbons will have a gap.

These interactions are hidden in nanotubes because the curvature of a nanotube reduces the coupling between more distant neighbors. However, they should have been observable in large-radius nanotubes, in which curvature effects are very weak. The authors do not appear to have addressed this point.

I realize that density functional theory is a powerful tool for investigating the electronic structure of many materials. However, I do not know that it has been used successfully in graphene. Moreover, the authors state that the particular DFT package they used is "especially tailored to take advantage of helical symmetry"--- a symmetry possessed by carbon nanotubes, but not graphene nanoribbons. Moreover, claims that the method "has been successfully used in wide-ranging studies of single walled carbon nanotubes" only refer to studies carried out by the authors.

I am uncomfortable with the idea of taking an empirical model -- the tight-binding model for electrons in graphene -- and adjusting its parameters to fit the results of a density functional calculation. It would be a different matter entirely if the “hidden interactions” were necessary to fit experimental data.

I was discussing a similar idea with my adivsor the other day. We had just listened to a talk in which a biophysicist described the molecular dynamics simulations he had developed to study fluctuating membranes. Because the model reproduced some features of the experimental data, he inferred that the model captured some important physical property of the real system. White et al. do the same thing here, making the claim that because the amended tight-binding model reproduces the results of the DFT calculation, there must be 2nd and 3rd nearest neighbor interactions in graphene.

What this type of reasoning lacks is a proof of a one-to-one correspondence between models and the physical properties of the system. I.e., one would have to establish that a particular model is the only one they could generate a particular physical property before making any conclusions about real graphene samples or fluctuating membranes. I do not believe this type of correspondence exists. At best, one might be able to argue that the model and the physical system fall into the same universality class in the sense of the renormalization group.

In the end, experimental studies will determine whether or not these hidden interactions are physically relevant. The same experiments will also assess the validity of the DFT calculation. It will be interesting to see whether all armchair nanoribbons are semiconductors.

End Interlude

Well, another 9 months have passed since my last post. Although, judging from the comments, I'm the only one who noticed.

I'm back now, and I've read some interesting articles. Let's not delay any longer.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Welcome Back

It's been quite some time since my last post. All of my writing efforts have gone toward producing the first draft of my Ph.D. dissertation, The Effects of Static Electric Potentials on Single Electrons and Excitons in Carbon Nanotubes: A Theoretical Study. I'm just about done --- with the first draft. I've got a 200 page monster with no figures and incomplete references that I've got to hammer into shape by the middle of May, but it's a lot better than staring at a blank page!

Although I haven't posted anything recently, I've been reading a lot. Going over background materials for my dissertation reminded me of how fascinating semiconductor physics, quantum field theory, and excitons are! I've had some time for deviations from my primary research focus as well. My pile of interesting papers continues to grow, plus I've started reading some textbooks on econophysics and nonlinear dynamics. Fascinating stuff.

Hopefully I'll get back in the habit of posting regularly. I hope to make the blog more friendly to others too. It will still primarily focus on interesting papers I've read (I'm still worried that once they go into my filing cabinet, I may never be able to find them again...), but I'd like to make the blog into more of a journal than a database. Maybe we can get a little dialog going on some topics. Maybe I can sharpen my skills at explaining complicated things in simple terms. Maybe I'll be so busy finishing my dissertation and finding a job that I won't have time for anything else. Who knows?

Check back in from time to time to see what's new. And drop me an e-mail if you like.


Jesse

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Peapods are the Same as Nanotubes

Transport Properties of Carbon Nanotube C_{60} Peapods

C.H.L. Quay, et al.

PRB 76, 073404 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRB/v76/e073404

In this article, the authors present data that suggest room temperature transport properties of carbon nanotube peapods are basically the same as unfilled carbon nanotubes. The peapods are either semiconducting or metallic and there is a Coulomb blockade.

The authors are surprised by the similarities with unfilled nanotubes. Since the nanotubes tested were selected from an ensemble containing mostly --- but not all --- peapods, one possible explanation is that the authors happened to select 7 unfilled nanotubes from the ensemble. They present a Bayesian statistical analysis to show that the chance of that happening are small, and that the most likely number of peapods in the experiment is roughly 6 of 7.

The authors' conclusion is that the transport properties of fullerene peapods are not that different from unfilled nanotubes. Although their statistical analysis seems correct, they could bolster their claim with more samples. I share their initial surprise that a lattice of buckyballs inside a nanotube has virtually no effect on its transport properties.

If the authors are correct, there are no signatures of the buckyball lattice in the transport spectra of a nanotube. How else might one go about detecting them?

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Photons and the Aharonov Bohm Effect

Bound on the Photon Charge from the Phase Coherence of Extragalactic Radiation

Brett Altschul

PRL 98, 261801 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e261801


The conclusion of this paper will come as a surprise to very few people: the photon probably doesn't have a charge. Altschul, from Indiana University, has deduced an upper bound on the photon charge that is 32 orders of magnitude less than the electron charge (46 if photons have both a positive and a negative charge). It is his analysis rather than his conclusion that I found interesting.

Altshcul's analysis starts from the observation that we can use interferometry to study astrophysical objects. Basically, one collects light from the same source at two different receivers. By studying the interference between the signals at the two receivers, one can obtain information about the source object. For this to work, the light from the source must be coherent --- i.e., the phase difference between two photons traveling along the same path must be small compared to the phase difference they acquire due to the path difference between the two receivers.

Altschul points out a source of phase difference that does not immediately come to mind: the Aharonov-Bohm Effect. If photons have a charge, then photons at the two detectors of an interferometer will acquire a phase difference that depends on the magnetic flux through the triangle made up of the two detectors and the source. (The assumption here is that a charged photon would interact with an external electromagnetic field exactly the same way an electron does.) The fact that interferometry works means the Aharonov Bohm phase small. (Conservatively, Altschul interprets "small" as "less than one".)

Making order of magnitude estimates for the interstellar magnetic field and using the baseline of the Very Long Baseline Interferometry Space Observatory Program (VSOP) with a source distance of 1 Gpc (about 3 billion light years), Altschul places an upper bound of 10^{-32} on the ratio of the photon charge to the electron charge.

The small bound is possible because of the huge distances involved in astronomical observations. It's almost like running a lab experiment designed to probe the Aharonov Bohm effect for 3 billion years --- that's a lot of data!

If the photon can have both positive and negative charges (like electrons) or positive, negative, and neutral charges (like pions), then the bounds are even tighter. This is because the Aharonov Bohm phase is proportional to the charge of the particle. If a particle with positive charge and a particle with negative charge travel along the same path, they acquire equal and opposite phases. If photons have two charges, the fact that interferometry works places an upper limit of 10^{-46} on the ratio of photon and electron charges.

The major source of uncertainty in this analysis is the current lack of understanding regarding interstellar magnetic fields. Perhaps Altschul's study will inspire new methods of studying these fields using interferometry.

As I said, the fact that the one can place a very small upper bound on the photon charge is not surprising. The fact that it can be done by analyzing the Aharonov Bohm effect is.

Altschul mentions a couple interesting facts about the theory of photons. First, the problem of the photon mass has been studied much more than that of photon charge. He mentions three theories of photon mass (Proca, Higgs, and Stuckleberg). I've never heard of the third. He also points out that not much is known about the consequences of charged photons. This is surprising, given the large number of models studied in quantum field theory --- many of which have little relevance to the physical world as revealed by experiments. It sounds like the kind of problem one might find at the end of a chapter in Peskin and Schroeder.

Wednesday, July 4, 2007

Relativity on the Table-Top

Dirac Equation and Quantum Relativistic Effects in a Single Trapped Ion

L. Lamata, J. Leon, T. Schatz, and E. Solano

PRL 98, 253005 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e253005

In this article, the authors demonstrate the experimental possibility of simulating a Dirac Hamiltonian in an atomic system. In short, they propose a table-top experiment that would probe the effects of a relativistic system.

The requirements are relatively modest. To simulate the (1+1)-D or (2+1)-D Dirac equation, one needs a two-level atomic system; for the (3+1)-D Dirac equation, one needs a 4-level system. Three types of couplings are also required:
• Carrier Interaction -- a resonant coupling between two of the internal atomic states (such as a laser tuned to the transition frequency).
• Jaynes-Cummings Interaction -- couples two internal states with a vibrational mode of the center of mass. An upward transition between internal states is accompanied by the destruction of a phonon.
• Anti-Jaynes-Cummings Interaction -- also couples two internal states with a vibrational mode, but the frequency is tuned so that an upward transition between is accompanied instead by the creation of a phonon.

When the phases of the laser fields used to generate the above interactions are appropriately tuned, the effective Hamiltonian for the two-level or four-level system is identical in form with the free Dirac equation. By varying the couplings, one can tune the effective particle mass and velocity of light.

The authors dedicate a lot of space to a discussion of Zitterbewegung, which is a rapid oscillatory motion of an electron about its mean position. It was predicted in 1930 by Schrodinger, but has not yet been observed experimentally. For electrons, the amplitude of the oscillations is on the order of 10^{-13} m, and the frequency is on the order of 10^{21} Hz. In addition, Zitterbewegung is an effect of the single-particle Dirac equation. There is some controversy over whether or not the effect persists in QED.

The authors point out that by controlling the effective electron mass and the effective speed of light, one should be able to bring the amplitude and frequency of the oscillations into an experimentally accessible range. Another point they don't mention: even if the effect does not occur for real electrons, the dynamics of their atomic system are (in theory) accurately described by a single-particle Dirac equation. Whether or not real electrons jitter around, the trapped ions on their desks should.

The authors mention a few other relativistic effects that might be simulated: by controlling the particle mass, one could observe something akin to the Higgs mechanism for mass generation; one could simulate the Klein paradox, in which particle-hole pairs are created in a strong potential; one could simulate a (1+1)-D axial anomaly, the lower-dimensional counterpart of the chiral anomaly in (3+1)-D.

The possibility of tuning the parameters of the Dirac equation is interesting. However, such simulations of relativistic systems is a bit perplexing. A similar situation exists in the theory of graphene and carbon nanotubes, where the low-energy excitations are described by a Dirac equation. On a very fundamental level, the simulation can't be right. So how far can one push the analogy?

How similar are a pseudospinor and a spinor? Electron spin has to do with angular momentum, but pseudospin has nothing to do with it. The simulated system can't have pseudospin-orbit coupling, but the Dirac equation can.

How effective is an effective speed of light? In the table-top simulation, nothing prohibits the electron or the center of mass of the ion system from exceeding the effective speed of light. What then? Would the authors claim they were simulating tachyons?

In the Klein paradox, where are the holes going to come from? No corresponding anti-cesium ion is going to materialize in the trap.

It would be quite interesting to probe these unphysical effects in a trap and see exactly how the effective Dirac physics breaks down.

A final note: This was a well-written paper, but I must criticize the authors for a particular choice of phrase. On page 2, they refer to the "notorious analogy" between the Dirac equation and the effective Hamiltonian of the trapped ion. Jesse James was notorious. The three-body problem is notoriously difficult. An analogy between Hamiltonians is not "famous or well known, typically for some bad quality or deed."

Saturday, June 16, 2007

The Geometry of Phase Space

Geometry of Hamiltonian Chaos

L. Horwitz, et al.

PRL 98, 234302 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e234302

This group from Israel has recast classical Hamiltonian dynamics in the language of differential geometry. In doing so, they have discovered a new criterion for chaotic motion: the deviation of parallel geodesics. The geodesics of the system are classical trajectories. If nearby geodesics diverge, it indicates an instability in the system. This is a different measure than the Lyapunov exponent, although it’s possible there is a deeper connection between the two. I would speculate that the Lyapunov exponents could be derived from this geometric theory.

The general idea behind the method is to rewrite the Hamiltonian using a metric in the space of conjugate momenta. From this metric, one can derive the connection and curvature. From the curvature, one can calculate geodesic deviation. However, the authors find that the geodesic equation and the Hamiltonian equations of motion do not agree. It turns out that the geodesics in the dual manifold (defined by dx^{i} = g^{ij} dx_{j}) do indeed agree with the Hamiltonian equations of motion. The authors simply state this fact without discussion. There must be a deeper significance of this result. Or maybe the authors just started their calculation on the wrong manifold. Regardless of the connection, the geodesics on the dual manifold and the Hamiltonian equations of motion are mathematically equivalent; thus, one has a geometric way of thinking about phase space trajectories.

The new connection is anti-symmetric, so there is torsion. I don’t know much about torsion. In my course on general relativity, one of the postulates we used in deriving Einstein’s equations was the “no torsion condition.” It has something to do with twist of the geodesics. It is irrelevant in the derivation of the authors because the antisymmetric terms cancel from the geodesic equation, leaving only a symmetric connection.

In the end, the authors find that the curvature derived from this connection determines the stability of an orbit. If the curvature is negative, geodesics diverge and the system is chaotic. If curvature is positive, geodesics converge, and the system is stable. This seems like a very useful tool for analyzing unstable systems. The authors point out that this approach does not require one to use approximations of the true equations of motion, unlike other methods.

The idea behind the paper is quite interesting. My one complaint with the paper is that the phrase “a complete discussion will be given elsewhere” was used at least four times, but the authors don’t indicate where. It would be interesting to see these discussions, as well as a discussion of the connection between the curvature studied by the authors and the Lyapunov exponents.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Excitons Insensitive to Environment

Screening of Excitons in Single, Suspended Carbon Nanotubes

A.G. Walsh, et al.

Nanoletters 7, 1485--1488 (2007)

URL: http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/abstract.cgi/nalefd/2007/7/i06/abs/nl070193p.html



This group from Boston University has investigated the binding energy of excitons in nanotubes as a function of the dielectric constant of the environment. They repeated photoluminescence measurements on nanotubes in dry air, humid air, and water. In general, they find that the binding energy is not very sensitive to changes in the dielectric environment. The binding energy only changes by a couple tens of meV between dry air and water.

The theoretical model they use is a 1D interaction of the form V / ( |z| + Z ). Surprisingly, they find that the parameter Z scales linearly with the dielectric constant! They claim this model was solved exactly in 1959. I’m going to track down that reference. With the exact solution and scaling relation for Z, they are able to reproduce the scaling of their data as well as a scaling relation reported by Perebeinos a couple years ago.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Exchange and Correlation in Graphene

Chirality and Correlations in Graphene

Y. Barlas, T. Pereg-Barnea, M. Polini, R. Asgari, and A.H. MacDonald

PRL 98, 236601 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e236601

This article was a pleasure to read. I've been reading about the use of techniques from field theory in condensed matter physics lately, and I got to see them in action here.

This group from Texas has evaluated the effects of exchange and correlation on the charge and spin susceptibility of graphene. They start from the massless Dirac equation that describes low energy excitations in graphene and calculate the interaction energy. The technique they used was new to me.

First, they write down an expression for the interaction energy that depends on the structure factor of the interacting system. The interaction energy appears to be calculated by adiabatically turning on the coupling between particles. The structure factor is calculated from the density-density response function, a relation based on the fluctuation dissipation theorem. The response function can be calculated in the random phase approximation using methods of quantum field theory. The authors combine a lot of neat tools to obtain the interaction energy. It's all condensed into one paragraph in this paper. I'll have to check out their reference, Giuliani and Vignale's "Quantum Theory of the Electron Liquid."

Though the techniques are well-established, they lead to surprising results in graphene. The authors find that the sign of the correections to the spin and charge susceptibilities is opposite that of the usual electron gas. The similarity of the response functions is also different from an electron gas. The exchange effect decreases the susceptibilities in graphene, while it enhances them in the normal 2DEG. The authors trace the difference in behavior to the renormalized fermi velocity, which increases with the interaction strength.

Once I am more comfortable with the techniques I'm learning from Abrikosov and Mattuck, I'm going to try and reproduce these results.

Wednesday, June 6, 2007

Ripping a Fluid Apart

Motion of a Viscoelastic Micellar Fluid around a Cylinder: Flow and Fracture

J.R. Gladden and A. Belmonte

PRL 98, 224501 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e224501

This duo from Penn state has experimentally demonstrated both the viscous and elastic regimes of a viscoelastic fluid. As with most fluid dynamics experiments, the photos are beautiful and fascinating.

Fluids flow. Solids deform or fracture. A viscoelastic fluid is a material that exhibits both types of response depending on how it is probed. In this Letter, Gladden and Belmonte have probed both types of response in a very simple way. The take a cylinder of diameter D and pull it through a layer of their fluid at constant velocity V. By varying the diameter and velocity, they observe three different types of response:

1) Flow: the fluid moves smoothly around the cylinder and recombines behind it.

2) Cut: the fluid still flows around the cylinder, but a cavity forms around it , and some air bubbles are trapped in its wake.

3) Tear: the cylinder rips through the fluid, leaving a trail of fin-shaped tears behind it, like a cylinder pulled through a thin plastic sheet.

These three types of response are displayed very effectively in Fig. 1. By plotting response as a function of V and D, the authors create a phase diagram for the fluid. There is a linear boundary between cut and flow, and a hyperbolic boundary between tear and the other two states. There is even a triple point.

The authors give an excellent discussion of their data. The boundary between flow and cut occurs when the time scale of fluid flow around the cylinder, D/V, exceeds the relaxation time of the fluid. The boundary between tear and the other two types of response has D*V constant. The authors use scaling arguments to determine the physical meaning of this constant, which is proportional to the tear strength of the fluid.

One more interesting observation is that when the cylinder is pulled fast enough, a crack forms in front of it. To analyze the stresses on the fluid, the authors used cross polarizers. They found a dipole pattern for the stress due to the moving cylinder, but the most fascinating picture from the paper is Fig. 6, the stress field due to a cubic probe. Amazing.

The pictures alone make this article worth reading. The authors analysis of the data is excellent.

Bubble Dynamics

Role of Dimensionality and Axisymmetry in Fluid Pinch-Off and Coalescence

J.C. Burton and P. Taborek

PRL 98, 224502 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e224502

A very interesting paper. Figure 2 is amazing!

This pair of researchers from UC Irvine has investigated two phenomena that occure at fluid interfaces: pinch off and coalescence. As the authors point out, these are topological transitions which involve a conversion of interfacial energy into kinetic energy of fluid flow.

Pinch off is what happens when a droplet is pulled apart. At some point it breaks up into two or more pieces. Coalescence is the merging of two droplets into one. The authors have used high-speed, high-resolution video to study these two processes for both two-dimensional and three-dimensional alkane droplets.

What Burton and Taborek observed in 2D pinch off blows me away. Watch the video. When a 3D droplet is pulled apart, it transforms into two globules connected by a thin filament just before pinch off. At one of the filament-globule interfaces, the filament separates, leaving a flat surface and a cone whose opening angle is determined by the fluid properties of the droplet. For the 2D droplets in this paper, the filament starts to pinch off at both ends, so there are two large globules on the left and right connected to a small globule in the middle. As these filaments pinch off, they repeat the process on a smaller scale. The authors observe 5 generations of successive pinch offs, with each generation of droplets smaller than its parents by a factor of 3. The end result is that a single droplet has broken up into about 30 smaller droplets, the smallest of which are almost 1000 times smaller than the original droplet. If that's confusing, watch the video. It's amazing!

Burton and Taborek did not observe any striking differences in the coalescence of 2D and 3D droplets. As two spherical droplets start to merge, the radius of the connected region grows linearly in time. At longer times, the radius grows with the square root of time. The authors use the two scaling laws to determine the approximate size of the droplet at the crossover. The crossover length scale is 2 orders of magnitude larger than the natural length scale of the fluid system.

This is a very interesting paper, with beautiful images, clean data, and insightful explanations.

Friday, May 25, 2007

Three Body Topology

Braids in Classical Dynamics

Christopher Moore

PRL 70, 3675--3679 (1993)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v70/p3675

This was a fascinating paper! I found it in the references of the paper on choreographic orbits. I never learned classical mechanics like this ...

In this paper, Moore analyzes orbits of N-body systems in 2+1 dimensions. He considers two-body potentials of the form

V(i,j) = A m(i) m(j) r(i,j)^X

as a function of the exponent X.

His approach to finding allowed orbits is novel. He suggests a topological classification. Basically, Moore starts out with a braid with N strands. (Every orbit in a plane defines a braid in 2+1 dimensions, and mathematicians know how to determine which braids are topologically equivalent.) Next, he defines an action for N-particle orbits whose minima are solutions of Newton's second law. He shows that starting with the braid and relaxing it toward a minimum of the action can result in only three things:

1) A particle flies off to infinity.
2) Two particles collide.
3) The braid relaxes to a topologically equivalent orbit that satisfies F = ma.

Armed with this tool, he examines the types of braids that yield solutions for a particular exponent X in the potential. First, he shows that escape is impossible if X < 2. That in itself is in interesting result. Next, he shows that for X <= -2, relaxation never leads to a collision. Thus, every braid is an allowed orbit for a potential that falls off at least as fast as 1/R^2.

The X=2 case is interesting because the system is integrable, and all particles orbit the center of mass with the same period. Moore shows that the only allowed braids are those in which any two particles have a winding number of +1 or -1 (as long as they don't collide at the origin). These are called harmonic braids.

After this, he reports numerical investigations of other braid types. He identifies solutions to solutions to the 3-body problem I didn't know about last week: the figure eight discussed in the choreographic orbits paper, and a braid I'll call the cross-circle. The table on page 3 is really interesting.

The application of topology to the 3-body problem is interesting and impressive. I'll have to get a copy of Arnol'd's book and see if I can learn a few of these methods.

Electric NMR

Electric Dipole Echoes in Rydberg Atoms

S. Yoshida, et al.

PRL 98, 203004 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e203004


This group from Rice has demonstrated the electric analog of spin echoes.

In NMR, spins precess around an applied magnetic field. Due to local variations in the magnetic field, not all spins precess at the same rate. However, one can apply a pulse that flips every spin in the sample, and all the spins basically reverse their motion. If the spins start precessing at t=0 and the flipping pulse (a pi-pulse) is applied at t=T, then at t=2T, all the spins will be right back where they started, even though they were precessing at different rates! The large magnetic moment of the sample at t=2T is called a spin echo. Effects like collisions, diffusion, thermal excitations, and other interactions prevent the system from returning to its exact initial configuration, but the echo can be detected after rather long delays.

So what does this have to do with electric dipoles? I learned that to first order in the applied field, the equation of motion for the electric dipole also describes precession. That's not exactly true --- the thing that actually precesses is a pseudospin comprised of the orbital angular momentum and something called the Runge-Lenz vector, which is proportional to the electric dipole moment. The difference of two pseudospins gives the Runge-Lenz vector. The authors say this is true of a classical dipole as well as the quantum theory.

One major difference between NMR and the experiment described here is that electric dipoles oscillate much more rapidly than magnetic dipoles. To make the relevant time scale as long as possible, the use Rydberg atoms --- potassium atoms in the n=350 level.

When they performed the experiment, the authors observed a marked increase of the survival probability when a flipping pulse was applied, in contrast with the exponential decay observed without the flipping pulse.

Another difficulty of this experiment versus NMR is the effect of the environment. Couplings to and interactions with spurious electric fields in the environment lead to much more rapid decoherence in the Rydberg gas than in a typical NMR sample. The authors point out that this is not necessarily a bad thing: dipole echoes could prove to be a useful tool in studying decoherence.

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Experimental Model of Graphene

Interlayer Interaction and Electronic Screening in Multilayer Graphene Investigated with Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy

T. Ohta, et al.

PRL 98, 206802 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e206802

This group from Berkeley has used the Advanced Light Source to generate a phenomenological tight-binding model for graphite samples with 1 to 4 layers. They used angle-resolved photoemission to construct the energy bands of their samples, then tuned the parameters of their tight-binding model to reproduce the observed band structure.

There were several interesting findings:

1) The splitting of the pi-electron bands in a 4-layer sample is nearly identical to that in bulk graphite. However, the hopping integral is larger in the layered sample and the screening length is smaller.

2) The charge density in the samples was nearly constant. It did not depend on the number of layers or the way in which they were stacked.

3) In layered samples, the oscillations of photoemission intensity as a function of momentum perpendicular to the beam are similar to those observed in quantized thin film states.

4) Single graphene sheets show no oscillations of this nature. The authors point out that there is more to this than the fact that graphene is only a single layer of carbon atoms. It indicates that there is virtually no interaction with the substrate. Graphene really is like an isolated 2D system.

5) The on-site Coulomb interactions differ from layer to layer. I have not seen this effect included in simple models of graphene bilayers. Then again, it's been a while since I read one of those papers.

General Relativity and Dance Steps

Choreographic Solution to the General Relativistic Three Body Problem

T. Imai, T. Chiba, and H. Asada

PRL 98, 201102 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e201102

This group from Hirosaki University in Japan has found a periodic solution of the 3-body problem for Newtonian gravity plus first order corrections from general relativity. Though the paper is not well-written and the background is not sufficient for understanding the group's work, I found the result interesting enough to read through all four pages.

I know a little about the three-body problem. My main impression is that there is no good way to separate coordinates and find a general solution. It admits both regular and chaotic solutions.

The authors provided some interesting historical background. Euler found one of the first solutions to the 3-body problem, with all three masses in a line. Though the distance between masses may change, the ratio of the distances does not. Euler found his solution in 1765. Seven years later, Laplace found a second, highly symmetric solution in which the three masses are at the corners of an equilateral triangle. According to the authors, these are the only solutions in which each particle's orbit is an ellipse.

Later, Poincare showed that not all solutions can be obtained analytically. In 1993, Christopher Moore found a solution in which all three particles move along a figure eight --- a very interesting solution to the problem! Moore was looking at general potentials in 2+1 dimensions and the types of braids the three bodies would weave in spacetime.

This figure eight, along with the solutions of Euler and Laplace, are examples of a more general class of solutions called choreographic orbits. In such an orbit, each of the three particles moves in a single closed orbit. It's as if all three particles are performing a dance routine. Some of Moore's braids are quite complicated indeed!

One of the best known effects of general relativity is the precession of Mercury's perhelion. Mercury's orbit around the sun is an ellipse with rotating axes. Therefore, it is not periodic (at least on short time scales). Do the effects of general relativity make choreographic orbits impossible?

The authors show that the first order corrections to Newtonian gravity do admit a figure eight solution, so at least some choreographic orbits are permitted. The authors had to choose the initial conditions carefully to obtain a periodic orbit.

In the conclusion, the authors point out that the higher order effects of general relativity might not have solutions. It seems to me that once gravitational waves are included, no periodic solutions will be possible. If a system is radiating away its energy, it can never return to its initial condition, thus the orbits of its constituent particles are not closed. I don't believe any 3-body system is symmetric enough that it would not emit gravitational wave.

Monday, May 21, 2007

Shining Light through a Wall with Axions

Transparency of the Sun to Gamma Rays Due to Axionlike Particles

Malcolm Fairbairn, Timur Rashba, and Sergey Troitsky

PRL 98, 201801 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e201801

Interesting stuff! The paper centers around the following logical deduction:

If axions allow light to pass through walls, then axions would allow gamma rays to pass through the sun.


• What is an axion?

An axion is a hypothetical pseudoscalar particle. (It behaves like a scalar function, except it changes sign under spatial reflections.) Axions cn couple to photons in a magnetic field. They are expected --- if they exist --- tobe light and weakly coupled.

Although the coupling between axions and photons is weak, it would have observable consequences. In a magnetic field, some light would be converted to axions, and interaction between left and right circularly polarized light would be mediated by axions. In QED, there is no coupling between the two opposite polarizations.


• Have axions been observed?

Maybe. An experiment called PVLAS detected a shift in the polarization of a laser passing through a strong magnetic field. The results are consistent with an axion mass of 1 meV and an inverse coupling of 100 TeV. However, an experiment called CAST claims to have ruled out a coupling that strong --- even though 100 TeV is a rather weak, unless you're a string theorist!


• How might one look for axions?

One method is that employed by the people at PVLAS: to search for polarization shifts in a strong magnetic field. However, the coupling of axions and photons offers a second, more exotic search technique: look for the transmission of light through an opaque object.

A strong magnetic field on one side of the object would convert some photons to axions. The axions would be able to pass through the object while the photons would not. A second strong magnetic field on the other side of the barrier would convert some of the transmitted axions back into photons, so it would appear that some light passed through the object. In short, if axions exist, then two strong magnetic fields would allow you to shine your flashlight through a rock!


• What's the sun got to do with any of this?

The group of physicists who wrote this paper believe that astronomical observations could determine the existence of axions. They have constructed a simple analytic model and numerically investigated a more detailed model, both of which predict the magnetic fields of the sun should allow the transmission of gamma rays through the sun via the axion-photon conversion process described above. The sun is normally opaque to gamma rays, and it does not produce a significant amount of gamma rays, so there should be little background interference.

The requirement for this type of observation is that a distant gamma ray source be identified whose line of sight from earth (or a space-based gamma ray detector) is eclipsed by the sun. If there are no axions, or if the coupling is too weak, the gamma ray source will disappear behind the sun. If gamma rays are still detected when the sun is between the source and the detector, it will provide strong evidence for the existence of axions.

There are gamma ray detectors on earth. Unfortunately for the authors, only one gamma ray source has been studied whose line of sight is obstructed by the sun. The statistics on this single source are not good enough to rule either way on the existence of axions, however the predicted and observed fluxes agree rather well. The flux definitely did not drop to zero when the sun obstructed the source.

In coming years, astronomical observations like those discussed by the authors may resolve the contradictory findings of PVLAS and CAST. The authors also suggest that decommissioned magnets from particle accelerators may allow for observation of axion-assisted photon tunneling in earth-based labs. No matter where the experimental data comes from, our knowledge of axions is going to increase quite a lot in the coming years.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Laser Cooling of Semiconductors

Surface Plasmon Assisted Laser Cooling of Solids

Jacob Khurgin

PRL 98, 177401 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e177401


Laser cooling of atoms is based on the Doppler effect. Laser frequencies are tuned below an atomic transition so that atoms moving toward the laser source will be more likely to absorb a photon than those moving away. The atom will then emit a photon in a random direction as it relaxes back down to its ground state, but the radiated photon will be of higher energy than the absorbed photon. As a result, the atom has radiated away some of its kinetic energy, so it has been cooled by a laser.

In solids the basic idea is similar. The solid absorbs one frequency of light and emits at a higher frequency, losing energy as a result. The mechanism is different, and it called anti-Stokes photoluminescence. Light is absorbed at a specfic frequency, then this excited state comes to thermal equilibrium with the system. Later, light is emitted at a higher frequency. The shift in frequency would be on the order of kT, where T is the temperature of the solid, and the system would gradually cool down.

Khurgin points out that there are several difficulties in the case of semiconductors. There are a lot of nonradiative decay channels, and the high index of refraction leads to low efficiencies --- i.e., even if you generate a photon of the right frequency, it's hard for it to get out of the semiconductor. One way to improve the efficiency is to make the density of absorbing states small and the density of emitting states large. When a photon is absorbed, the energy is more likely to be transferred to a higher-energy emitting state than to remain in the absorbing state for a time, then be re-emitted at the same frequency.

Khurgin's approach to the problem is to exploit surface plasmon polaritons. These occur at the interface between a dielectric and a metal at frequencies where the dielectric constants of the two media are equal in magnitude but opposite in sign. The density of plasmon states has a sharp resonance, which leads to an increase of spontaneous emission at the resonant frequency. (Apparently, Purcell worked this out back in 1946.)

Khurgin notes that the plasmon modes still have to couple to radiative modes before they give up their energy, so it might seem that nothing has been gained. However, he goes on to demonstrate that the plasmons can couple to the phonons of the metal. The metal will heat up, but the goal was never to cool the metal and the dielectric together --- only to cool the dielectric medium.

Based on this observation, Khurgin proposes placing a layer of silver on top of a gallium arsenide layer with a gap between them of a couple nanometers. The gap is a thermal insulator between the silver and gallium arsenide. The only coupling between the two systems are the plasmons. A laser will produce excitations in the gallium arsenide layer, and many of these will relax into the many available plasmon modes. The plasmon modes will couple to the phonon modes in silver, but not in gallium arsenide, so they will gradually transfer energy from the semiconductor to the metal. This four-step process leads to laser cooling of the semiconductor:

laser ---> semiconductor excitations ---> plasmons ---> phonons in metal

Khurgin estimates that the silver and gallium arsenide system could have a cooling efficiency of 2 percent or more.

Light to Atom to Light Again

Reversible State Transfer between Light and a Single Trapped Atom

A.D. Boozer, A. Boca, R. Miller, T.E. Northup, and H.J. Kimble

PRL 98, 193601 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v98/e193601

This group from Cal Tech claims the first demonstration of the transfer of a coherent state between a photon and an atom, then from the atom back to a photon. This is a necessity for a quantum network.

Much work in quantum computing has gone into developing and manipulating qbits. It's one thing to have a single working qbit in isolation, or a pair, or 16 of them. But if you want to develop a quantum computer with a large number of qbits, or if you want to transfer the output state of your computation somewhere else, what do you do? The authors suggest that coherent light would be able to transfer superpositions of quantum states over optical fibers. Transmitting light over optical fibers is not so hard. The difficult step is turning an atomic state into a photon, transmitting the photon, then turning the photon into the same atomic state somewhere else.

In this letter, the Cal Tech group demonstrates "the reversible mapping of a coherent optical field to and from the hyperfine ground states of a single trapped cesium atom."

The prototype for their experiment is a 3-level atom. The atom has two ground states |a> and |b>, and an excited state |e>. The atom is in an optical cavity that couples |b> and |e>, and an external field couples |a> and |e>. If the external field is turned on slowly, the state |a,n> is transformed into |b,n+1> --- i.e., there is a transition between atomic states and a single photon is generated in the cavity. Slowly turning the field off reverses the transition.

If the cavity is empty, the process can be used to generate a single photon. The atom is prepared in state |a,0> and the field is slowly turned on. The resulting state is |b,1>. This is interesting, but transitions between single atomic states are not the building blocks of quantum computing. Entanglement and coherent superpositions of states are the tools of the trade. The useful thing about the process just described is that is works on a superposition of states:

(A |a> + B |b> ) |0> <---> |b> ( A |0> + B |1> )

This represents the transfer of a superposition of atomic states to a superposition of photon states, and all that was required is the turning off of a classical field.

The authors never mention the word "entangled" when discussing their experiments. I don't know what the exact definition of entangled states is, but I recall something about the impossibility of writing such a state as a product of states. If this is true, then the relation above does not describe the transfer of an entangled state from atom to photon. Still, it's a good first step!

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Phonon Effects in Graphene

Electron-Phonon Coupling Mechanism in Two-Dimensional Graphite and Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes

G.G. Samsonidze, E.B. Barros, R. Saito, J.Jiang, G. and M.S. Dresselhaus

PRB 75, 155420 (2007)

URL: http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRB/v75/e155420

The authors have analyzed the effects of phonons on the fermi energies and wave vectors of graphene. Their analysis is based on the group theory of the wave vector and demonstrates both the power of the technique and my lack of understanding.

They observe two phenomena associated with the phonons. First, there is a Pierls instability, which means the phonon modes open up a frequency-dependent band gap. The second is a Kohn anomaly, which is electron screening of a particular phonon mode.

Section 2 and Appendix A are very useful, as they show the general procedure for introducing phonon effects into the tight-binding model. When the phonon mode breaks the symmetry of the lattice, the unit cell of graphene must be enlarged to become a supercell of six atoms. This leads to a 6 by 6 Hamiltonian instead of the more familiar 2 by 2 version. However, the larger Hamiltonian is what Wigner calls a supermatrix --- a matrix composed of smaller matrices. There are two diagonal 3 by 3 matrices for the on-site terms, H[AA] and H[BB]. The hopping terms are described by two 3 by 3 matrices, H[AB] and H[BA], with every entry equal to t (for k=0). The latter is surprising, as it suggests that every A site is connected to every B site --- a fact that is not obvious from the diagrams provided by the authors.

This Hamiltonian gives a six-band spectrum, with the middle four bands degenerate. The K-point phonon mode breaks the degeneracy from fourfold to twofold and opens a bandgap that depends on the phonon coupling strength and amplitude.

The appendix gives the corresponding Hamiltonian for phonons with wave vectors not at a highly symmetric point of the Brillioun zone. It is not as symmetric. Although the authors do not analyze the energy bands of the general tight-binding Hamiltonian with phonon interactions, I assume that a phonon that does not respect any symmetries of the underlying lattice would lift all the degeneracies. The only exception might be the Kramers degeneracy imposed by time-reversal symmetry.

One aspect of this work I don't understand is why the phonon modes considered by the authors are more important than others. Are they the modes of lowest energy? Do the phonon bands cross the electron bands at the fermi energy? It seems that they are simply the easiest to analyze, but that does not mean their physical effects are the most important.